It was sad that the vivacious and gregarious Kajol, who was awaiting the release of a very special family film, “U, Me Aur Hum”, lost her father a day before. Life has a way of striking death blows, that leaves one completely numb and shocked. Incidentally, the film also refers briefly to the relationship of the protagonist (played by Kajol) and her father.
Coming to the film, what I liked:
1.The courage of the Devgans to produce a film on a diabolic disease with complete commitment.
2. But, of course, Kajol’s stunning performance. Her performance is heart wrenching and pulls at your heart strings.
3. The concluding scene between Ajay and Kajol.
4. The scenes where Kajol forgets everything and the world just swirls around on a busy road.
What I disliked:
1. Verbalising about emotions – everything from love to relationships to marriage when subtleties can be made to work brilliantly.
2. Too much of close-up shots.
3. The inane beginning and the portrayal of the couples (Divya Dutta is irritating to say the least whereas Summet Raghavan, who plays her husband, is completely lovable).
4.The adult jokes (not at all required for the script).
For more, read http://www.rediff.com/movies/2008/apr/11hum.htm
A few thoughts about the way the disease has been dealt in the film: Should a patient suffering from Alzheimer’s disease be left with the family or under institutional care ? The film is clear on this — a patient suffering from the disease can recuperate best with the spouse/family. It completely rules out institutional care as a method of curing such patients. Though spouse/family is the best healer of any disease, I really don’t know if institutional care can be completely ignored..